By Roldo Bartimole
As I reach the age of 80 it is hard for me to believe that my life has taken roads that I would never have foreseen. It has been an unexpected life journey. So I take liberty now to speak of it.
Never would I have believed as a youngster that I would become a radically different person than I ever could have imagined of myself. I am timid, if anything. Truth is, early in life, I had no special expectations for myself. No great or even strong goals. I took the most general of subjects in high school. I could have anticipated life as a clerk, having worked in my dad’s butcher/grocery store. Only because of the GI bill did I even think of college. After two years in the Army, I entered business school at Northeastern University, hardly a choice I would have made years later.
It was 50 years ago my path changed. What I saw and experienced did it. I was working at the Bridgeport Sunday Post, my hometown paper. I had worked sports for the morning edition in 1959, left for a news position in Haverhill, Mass. I was lured back months later with an offer to be an assistant to the Sunday editor.
In January, 1963 the New Yorker magazine published a historic piece by Dwight McDonald entitled “Our Invisible Poor.” It was a book review of Michael Harrington’s “The Other America – Poverty in the United States.” Together these writings prompted (or shamed) President John F. Kennedy’s War on Poverty.
Similarly, the times prodded me. I looked at the 1960 U. S. Census of Bridgeport, Conn. And I was on my way to change. I saw too much to be a mere bystander. I chose three of the poorest census tracts to examine.
My travels showed me the location of the worst poverty and housing in my home city. I hadn’t known.
I began to walk those streets. And enter those buildings. I was shocked by what I saw and heard. I learned what real poverty was.
I’ll never have to wonder why some children don’t/can’t learn. I visited “apartments” where ill-vented space heaters, feet from the beds of children, sucked the oxygen from the room and their lungs. You can’t inhale fumes that dull your brain for years and succeed academically.
I have the news clipping of an attic room with newspapers and cardboard on the walls and ceiling, crude attempts to keep the cold out. A child stands next to an open space heater, the only heat. The reaction of public officials: I had torn some cardboard from the unfinished roof to make the scene appear worse. Just pathetic thinking.
Worse, you can’t survive fire in crowded rooms with few escape options.
Five children died in one tenement I had visited and written about in the paper. It was devastating. A civic leader spoke the truth: They were “expendable.”
Expendable children?
Soon the powers that be – a mayor and editors – got very nervous. This continuous exposure of deadly housing didn’t look good for City Hall. Or for the city of Bridgeport.
Shit was getting disturbed. Some reacted.
In June 1963 I was honored by a host of citizens: “Roldo Bartimole who in his newspaper reporting has had the wisdom of seeing clearly and the courage of speaking that which has seen” from “his many friends of Bridgeport’s civic and social agencies.” It was an honor I treasure. It wasn’t a journalism award. It was from citizens, including the president of the NAACP.
My employers didn’t quite see it that way.
I was told what every aggressive reporter will eventually hear: STOP.
No more stories about dilapidated, over-priced and dangerous housing. Let’s not concentrate public discussion on dispensable children.
Yes, life had changed. I too had changed too. You can’t un-ring a bell.
I did stop doing housing articles. Or any others. I was stubborn. Brash. (Stupid?). Potential story ideas given to me went into a bottom drawer.
I was soon gone.
But happily so. There was another Bridgeport paper, the Sunday Herald. Owned by Leigh Dannenberg. He was labeled a communist by the right-wing Hearst columnist Westbrook Pegler. He telephoned me and asked me to see him. I did. I hear you’re gagged over there, he said. Want to come here? Yes. And I did.
Eventually, I made my way to Cleveland in 1965. To the Cleveland Plain Dealer, as it was known then. To a city in racial turmoil.
At the PD I learned more about how things work. How power operates. For whom it works. For whom it does not work. I had many lessons from the beginning. Jack Reavis of Jones, Day, Reavis & Pogue, explained to the U. S. Civil Rights Commission, how power worked in Cleveland. Talking of corporate efforts to deal with racial problems, Reavis said, “… I secured a pledge from the editors of the newspapers (PD & Press) that they would give us no publicity except as we asked it because everybody in the group thought we could work better privately.” Well, of course. That’s really how it works. In the back rooms. Censorship by corporate and editorial collaboration. Plain and simple. Blatant when required.
Soon again I left the newspaper. I went to work in the poverty program in Summit County.
Just as in Bridgeport, I was lured back to the paper by the offer of the welfare beat. To me this was where I belonged. Writing about urban problems, especially poverty. Poverty was a leading Cleveland commodity in 1967.
Again, the inability to write it as I saw it became a problem. I had to slip in what I thought I’d get away with to tell truth. A reporter at the Wall Street Journal who covered urban issues here was leaving. Dave Vienna suggested to his boss, Clayt Sutton, bureau chief of the WSJ, that they hire me. And the Journal did.
I lasted some eight months.
On April 5, 1968 I arrived full circle on my unexpected life journey. Incidentally, it was my 35th birthday. The day after the assassination of the Rev. Martin Luther King, Jr. A bitterly sad day.
I attended a conference at the Aurora Inn that day. Professors, as I remember it, from state colleges all over Ohio were meeting.
It was a historic day. Riots had broken out in many cities the previous night. Urban American was burning.
The main speaker at the conference was a black man. George Wiley, a chemistry professor turned activist. He headed the National Welfare Rights Organization in D. C. He told the all-white audience he would no longer plead with whites for understanding. That, however, was what he was doing. Trying to tell how it felt to be black on that dismal day.
The reaction he got was distressing. The audience of educators was reproachful, bemoaning the civil strife and the rioters. The shock of Dr. King’s killing for African-Americans seemed not to matter. It seemed inconsequential. How could this be?
These experiences and the times – anti-war protests and civil rights conflict of the 60s – indicated to me – by no means a courageous person – that life had changed. I must, too. I quit my job at the Journal and started a small newsletter – Point of View – in May of 1968. I charged $3 a year and had a mere 300 subscribers by the end of the year. It was a start. This task lasted 32 and a half years.
Those issues of inequality remain today. Maybe more acutely. Because who cares now about injustice?
My unexpected journey continues. Who knows for how much longer?
---
The photo accompanying this piece shows a young girl, Kim, standing next to a dangerous space heater. It sits a few feet from her bed. I wrote, “The room is an ideal example of what a child’s bedroom should not be like. It might be considered a classic example of a fire hazard. There is no insulation between the cardboard (ceiling) and the roof. The ceiling is about eight feet from the floor. The floor has weak spots which have been bolstered by odd pieces of wood.”
In 1991 he was awarded the Second Annual Joe Callaway Award for Civic Courage in Washington, D.C. He received the Distinguished Service Award of the Society of Professional Journalists, Cleveland chapter, in 2002, and was named to the Cleveland Journalism Hall of Fame, 2004. [Photo by Todd Bartimole.]
15 Responses to “ROLDO: Roldo’s Unforeseen Journey”
Anastasia Pantsios
Very moving, Roldo. Not much has changed at the Plain Dealer, which is why I am ambivalent about its long, slow death. Management still sees it as a mouthpiece for the Jones, Day of today, the Greater Cleveland Partnership. It would rather ignore what goes on with real people — why it was years later on the foreclosure story. And when it did do the story, it didn’t actually tell the story. It went with anomalies that could make a reader feel superior to those people whose houses were being taken. I know it’s the way big metro dailies are and alway have been. But that doesn’t stop me from longing for something different.
Steve Hatch
Hey Roldo,
My admiration for you and your work remain boundless. Keep up your good and necessary work–Telling truth to and about the powerful and shining a much needed light on the powerless. And keep in mind always, that 80 is the new 50.
Larry Durstin
Roldo,
You’ve left an indelible mark on the consciousness of Greater Cleveland. Keep going.
Roldo Bartimole
Thanks to all for your comments and encouragement.
Richey, glad you’ve added your voice here.
Thanks to James, Laurie, Jeanne, Allison, who reunites after being a POV
subscriber, and Janis, via my daughter Karin.
David, Dick, Larry & Anastasia, you know the media from vast experience.
I have to agree it isn’t getting better and likely will get much worse.
I noticed a report on TV last night involving Cleveland residents protesting the recent murders of two women and attempted rape of another in a small area of the city. There was brief TV film of the terrible, dirty conditions along the streets there- it looked like no curbing – in the relatively small area where these crimes were committed. Total neglect by the city, thus an invitation to crime. I then remembered a letter to the editor of Crain’s Cleveland a week ago from the board chairman of the Historic Warehouse District Development Corp. bragging of city improvements in that small area. It noted that the city was in the midst of investing some $2 million in road improvements, new bricks and repaving of streets in that area, and some $650,000 for “streetscapes” on portions of West 6th Street. I remember tens of millions of public dollars pledge to the East Bank of the Flats nearby. Yet I never see or read of the unequal distribution of city resources between the subsidy-soaked downtown and Cleveland’s needy neighborhoods. The Plain Dealer did a very bad job of covering the sale of the downtown administration building by the school board, under Mayor Frank Jackson, which led to little discussion of the meaning of the sale and what is going to happen to land around the building. This inability to encourage public discussion by the media, particularly the PD, contrasts with the paper’s whining about some public official not releasing some public information. Wonder if slothful, sensational, trite and inconsequential TV news will try to help the public understand what’s going on when the PD further abdicates its responsibilities with more staff and publication cutbacks. If it could get worse I don’t know how. The Newhouse family, owners of the PD, have never been known for their interest in Cleveland beyond how much money they could pull out. Sad.
Dale Maharidge
Roldo: This is a beautiful piece of writing. A lot has not changed–editors still don’t want to run these kinds of stories. The big mainstream book publishers are more focused on the bottom line than ever. We have to keep fighting to get these stories out there. May you be able to do so for many, many more years. –Dale Dale Maharidge.
Peanuts
Thank you for all you do, Roldo. Long may you run. Bridgeport’s loss was Cleveland’s gain in this case.
snarky
Roldo , Your work and dedication is lasting and living tribute to your proffesion.
May you be still raking about the muck when the cows come home to downtown Cleveland.
snarky
Sorry about the typo , ” profession “is the word , and I am the worst two finger typist in the world.
Roldo Bartimole
Dale: Thanks for your remarks. They are especially
meaningful coming from someone who has written
and done so much for people not served and discarded
by our society.
By all means, readers check out Dale Maharidge’s books.
A Cleveland guy, too.
Stephen G. Esrati
This is great — but incomplete. Among Roldo’s other successes is in his critical view of the media. Those of us who worked on The PD read Roldo to find out what was happening at 1801 Superior Ave,
It is also wonderful to find the name of Peter Phipps among those who commented. Peter was the only local media reporter at the John Demjanjuk trial who knew what was going on (I was the stringer for a Cabadian paper, the Canadian Broadcasting Co. and the National Jewish Post and Opiinion.)
Scott Raab
Bless you and thank you, Roldo. I’m 60, and I can’t remember a time when you were not speaking truth to power with clarity and courage. Don’t ever stop.
robert
Bless You roldo….sad part…STILL have all this ‘going on’…just less or lot less of it…if ANY sense of justice or solace…YOU tried..and more or less succeeded…take that for what it is worth…for a near 80 yr old You are the boss!…. IF want to to look at THIS another way… THE INTERESTS and biz have created such a mucked up mess in a sense a BARACK does look like a Savior cuz folks take a look at alternatives,gulp and went for Barack…….Heck…HILLARY looks like a Savant Genius and it took 20 yrs for folks to rally around Her….
TO a point folks can STILL work selves out of poverty&/or get help thou THAT is HARDER to do now vs.the old days…SOME just have some real bad issues whether ADHD or other ‘problems’ and are just much harder to help….with sometimes tragic results….one does what one can do…the official system stuck in a quandary….PR wise and every sense of the word…..
robert
Sad when DEMS stuck playing trickledown economics…..suspect THEY threw up their hands,went with the interests, rallied around likes of MedMart,crosses figners, waiting for short term barrage of brickabats for awhile and then back to normal…..AND say NOW ON US to save selves cuz “THEY” provided the ‘means’ via jobs,etc.via said ‘projects’……IF ANY karma PAYBACK time when THEY try n canvass for contributions,politico support…. GUESSING that…. SAD changed out that low $ factory or service job for flinging a mop down at MediMart or some other such wunderproject but hey…. FOR some it provides a ‘cover’…guess some value there in all that….
I HATE to say this but BEST thing is SMALLER population…FEWER people to torture,humiliate and/or be a PR horror…
robert
IF want to look at THIS way….when ENOUGH people get mucked with…wont be good for biz…in the end… THEY almost cant stand the chaos,inanity…and politicos look worse and dumber for stuff they back..which to a point I THINK is part of Legrandiose Master Plane but what do I know…
Brian Cummins
Roldo, thanks for sharing more about your life experiences. The pursuit of real engagement with people and circumstances has very powerful impacts on our lives. Thanks for your writing but most importantly here, the source of inspiration and motivation for your work!